Re: The Mafia Revolutions [Day 4]

by **Ksarme** November 17th 2012, 7:08 pm

I'm not trying to act smart, I'm just thinking when I play. Something you're not doing.

by **.::Nakato::.** November 17th 2012, 7:10 pm

oh no, axer is onto me o-o

by **Crimson** November 17th 2012, 7:17 pm

Thel_JF wrote:
Axer wrote:So.
Clue #1: LG get's killed by the mafia.
That means that a majority or mafias, or at least 2 of them are people who participated in and followed the last round, as they were able to win the vote.
Clue #2: Vigilante shooting Thel... probably someone wants revenge for the last round. Satamino?
Clue #3: Thel saved by the doctor, what indicates that he is the doctor himself (odds of random doc intervention during the first night are incredibly low).

What leaves me with the list:
Spoiler:

All things summed up and after rolling my d8, the accused person will be: Itachi.Byakuya.

clue 1 and 3 are really random
every1 knows that lightninger is scary for mafia guys
and for clue3 well a lot of people like me and if one of them is the doc they will obviously help me esp in the first round when theres no one else to help yet

+ it makes you suspicious that u didnt even comment on the stunkata accusation
which makes me think that you and stunkate are mafias
and youre just trying to act smart like last round

Thel, acting smart is not a sin. And the clues aren't that random - not everybody played in round 1, so not everybody knows about LG being a danger to mafia guys. About clue 3, it's not all that random, but it is strange, that he's saying it out aloud. On one hand it's like he's telling the mafia, that youre a doctor. On the other, if he were mafia, couldn't he just PM his mates about his thoughts??

And I dunno about the Stun accusation. Some ppl take this game seriously, others might not. I dunno, why he was so happy, maybe he just liked the story Div made up.

by **DoM!n** November 17th 2012, 7:19 pm

I'm extremely buttdevastated right now

by **Remilia Scarlet** November 17th 2012, 7:21 pm

Yeh, he said so himself that he just liked the way Divisor creates stories out of the game.

Stunkata8 wrote:Just let me defend myself with these next rows
I'm not proud man
I just really liked the way divi's getting the stories in to the game - I wasn't here for the last one, so if they were in there too I wasn't aware of that, and it cracked me up - Thats all.

Still not accusing anyone though.

by Thel_JF November 17th 2012, 7:29 pm

Crimson wrote:
Thel_JF wrote:
Axer wrote:So.
Clue #1: LG get's killed by the mafia.
That means that a majority or mafias, or at least 2 of them are people who participated in and followed the last round, as they were able to win the vote.
Clue #2: Vigilante shooting Thel... probably someone wants revenge for the last round. Satamino?
Clue #3: Thel saved by the doctor, what indicates that he is the doctor himself (odds of random doc intervention during the first night are incredibly low).

What leaves me with the list:
Spoiler:

All things summed up and after rolling my d8, the accused person will be: Itachi.Byakuya.

clue 1 and 3 are really random
every1 knows that lightninger is scary for mafia guys
and for clue3 well a lot of people like me and if one of them is the doc they will obviously help me esp in the first round when theres no one else to help yet

+ it makes you suspicious that u didnt even comment on the stunkata accusation
which makes me think that you and stunkate are mafias
and youre just trying to act smart like last round

Thel, acting smart is not a sin. And the clues aren't that random - not everybody played in round 1, so not everybody knows about LG being a danger to mafia guys. About clue 3, it's not all that random, but it is strange, that he's saying it out aloud. On one hand it's like he's telling the mafia, that youre a doctor. On the other, if he were mafia, couldn't he just PM his mates about his thoughts??

And I dunno about the Stun accusation. Some ppl take this game seriously, others might not. I dunno, why he was so happy, maybe he just liked the story Div made up.

kk have to agree with the stunkata thing

but regarding clue 3
theres really no way he can know that im doctor as long as he didnt check me
but even then and if it was true why would he tell everyone
hes a potential mafia as well then cause there is a spy among them
-> he cant just send his results to every mafia member so hes telling everyone that im the doctor because he wants me dead

by **Ksarme** November 17th 2012, 7:45 pm

Crimson wrote:About clue 3, it's not all that random, but it is strange, that he's saying it out aloud. On one hand it's like he's telling the mafia, that youre a doctor. On the other, if he were mafia, couldn't he just PM his mates about his thoughts??

Um. It's not that it's the most obvious thing to figure out (I can't think of any turn of events that would lead to Thel knowing that someone will attack him, finding the doctor at random [or having the doctor reveal himself to him] and convincing him to save Thel's life...) and clarifying it when creating your "black" list to explain why someone isn't there is a pretty standard thing to do.

@Thel: Except for the fact that the doctor saved you on the very first night, no, there is no way of figuring out.
Seriously, how many doctors on the first night protect someone other than themselves?
And why the hell are we even having this argument...? The doctor is the one role that can be safely revealed, because he just isn't a good target for the mafia, due to his ability. And if the citizens can be sure someone can be trusted, it's for the best, as then the city can force vote on anyone during the day and mafias can't oppose without looking suspicious. Makes executing mafias hell of a lot easier.

by **analzooro** November 17th 2012, 7:47 pm

Axer wrote:
Clue #3: Thel saved by the doctor, what indicates that he is the doctor himself (odds of random doc intervention during the first night are incredibly low).

How is this random? It makes perfect sense,the only reason a doctor wouldn't protect himself would be if the doctor thinks an important citizen is in danger of getting killed.(ex. someone like Lg or Axer).
and since thel isn't smart or important i'm sure he's the doctor

by **Crimson** November 17th 2012, 8:02 pm

Then... why are you explaining it even more blatantly? If he is a doctor, then it's not ok for it to be known well... yeah?

by **analzooro** November 17th 2012, 8:06 pm

If citizens know how is the doctor,they won't accuse him,at night he can defend himself from mafia attacks,if thel is a doctor he isn't in danger at all.

by **Remilia Scarlet** November 17th 2012, 8:08 pm

Crimson wrote:Then... why are you explaining it even more blatantly? If he is a doctor, then it's not ok for it to be known well... yeah?

Yeh... let's stop this already, there's really no help for us to say "HEY, MAFIAS! The doctor is right here!"

by **Crimson** November 17th 2012, 8:08 pm

Ooops, just read your post Axer. Hope double posting isnt bad here.

Anyways, it makes sense that killing a doctor isn't that lucrative a trade - he doesn't know anybody, so the chances of him saving somebody are low. Ugh, but later on he's very useful, so maybe killing him of early on is good for mafia.

by **Crimson** November 17th 2012, 8:15 pm

Got a ghost message:

LiGhtninGeR wrote:

"Last Night, I got two PMs: from Lars and from Stunkata. Lars wanted to team up with me, I rejected that since I don't know his role yet. Then Stunkata PMed me saying that "I need a doctor". He said that he is the Spy and he got a PM from Lars who said him that they should vote me, Axer and Bourne last Night. Stunkata quickly contacted some falks and got a PM from Domin who said that they (Mafias) should go with me first.

So, if you believe Stunkata, then the Mafias are: Domin and Lars, and the Citizens are: me, Axer and Bourne. Domin got killed by Neo last Night and he truly is Mafia. And I also got killed by Mafias, just like Stunkata said.

But, there is also a possible second story behind all of this: Maybe Stunkata is a Mafia man who decided to gain my confidence and trust by saying me that I'll get killed and revealing 2 Mafias to me? Maybe that's all a plan from the start? What Stunkata said was all true, but in this way he could be safe for a long time (probably untill the real Spy discover himself).

It's up to you to decide will you believe Stunkata or not. I suggest killing Lars and if he really turns out to be the Mafia, Stunkata is probably innocent. But it would be nice to get the Sheriff as soon as possible to check him in any case. But first the two Sheriffs need to find out what kind of Sheriffs they are (Newbie or the real one).

That's everything I know, wish you luck with this, LG."

Citizens, please unite.

by **analzooro** November 17th 2012, 8:17 pm

Yea neat accusing Lars.

by **Stunkata8** November 17th 2012, 8:18 pm

I do in fact remember a game when the doctor had saved a citizen in the late game and with that stoped the mafia plans - that was long ago, most of the times I remember doctors getting revealed day 1 and the most value we can get from that is saving a citizen from being lynched>

HAHAHAHAHA! YOU DID NOT JUST POST THAT awesome

by **[S]ky** November 17th 2012, 8:56 pm

Dudes I killed the lawyer

by **Remilia Scarlet** November 17th 2012, 9:05 pm

Sky, why did you waste your big powers just to fuse with a random pershon when you could spy on 2 people at once and still live? Oh well, not that it will change anything now.

by **Stunkata8** November 17th 2012, 9:07 pm

Dudes, will this round continue awesome

by Thel_JF November 17th 2012, 9:17 pm

stunkata so lars is mafia as well?
and btw anal im sorry that ure a jellyfish xDDD

by **Ksarme** November 17th 2012, 9:27 pm

Hah. I actually believe this story. Lars knows why *cough skype cough*.
Changing accusation to lars5666.

by **Miatsu** November 17th 2012, 9:35 pm

Well, kind of hard to argue with evidence like that. I believe it as well. Accusing Lars5666

by -Shivam- November 17th 2012, 9:47 pm

Changing accusation to lars

by **Stunkata8** November 17th 2012, 9:48 pm

Well kay then let me accuse lars and get the information I have out there:
It's basicly a list of people that trough my talks with the mafia, I got the expression they are all citizens, because I was told its okay for any of them to get lynched:
Those are A and Itachi, also Axer who was second on the mafia kill list and Bourne.
I also believe Vuzi is a citizen

by **Remilia Scarlet** November 17th 2012, 10:13 pm

Damn you Divisor for suddenly adding Ghost mode and ruining me oh shit

(now let me watch anime in peace)

by **analzooro** November 17th 2012, 10:34 pm

lars5666 wrote:Damn you Divisor for suddenly adding Ghost mode and ruining me

(now let me watch anime in peace)

get smoked,scrub

by Sponsored content